Skip to main content

I was reading an article where a personal finance consultant used a personal loan from Upstart to pay off some credit card debt. I was curious what everyone thought of that idea. 

For my particular case, I'm torn 50/50. (First I had to admit my mistake & big 'oops' moment realizing I have about 10k in credit card debt now... yikes.) I know the absolute #1 way to fix this is to budget and change spending patterns, which I'm already doing. The concept of a personal loan intrigues me though as another way to combat this debt. I know there are pros (lower interest rate for one) and cons (like another ding to my credit score). Here's my example:

  • Card 1- 1135 owed 26.24%
  • Card 2- 2925 owed 25.74%
  • Card 3- 1230 owed 26.15%
  • Card 4- 810 owed 22.15%
  • Card 5- 900 owed no interest till 9/20
  • Card 6- 991 owed 25.14%
  • Card 7- 1430 owed 25.99%

I should clarify that these are all the household cards. The total payments on these is about $350 a month. Now I looked at Upstart's options for my situation.

  • Loan 1- $10,000 5 year 18.4%
  • Loan 2- $12,500 5 year 18.95%

I included a sort of balloon amount as an "in case" on option 2. Both options are lower than the $350/month payments we already make at $247 and $313.

What would you do in this case, fellow Penny Hoarders? Would you take one of the loans to ensure a lower interest rate? Or would you tackle the current card usage with the avalanche or snowball method? 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Personally, I would tackle the current card situation with the snowball method. I would do this because I might be tempted to continue adding to credit card debt if it were back at 0$, and because I have seen time and time again clients of mine do that very thing. 

So yes I realize that the interest rate is higher. But personally, that is what I would do, and what I did do. 

@KellyFromKeene That's totally fair! I don't think I'd be tempted to spend with the balances down, but I realize that life happens and it's not a guarantee. (Or else I probably wouldn't even have considered the loan idea.) 

The snowball method is what I'm doing for now, but I'm hoping once a card or two are paid off, I can focus on the highest interest rate. Hopefully the combination of momentum and fighting back the interest will prove successful!

My husband & I just consolidated our credit card debt with a personal loan. My first advice is to go to a bank (credit union preferably) to seek your personal loan options there. Upstart gave us interest rates around 18% as well, but our credit union was able to give us a rate of 7.99%! However, depending on if you own a home, a home equity line of credit is another option. You are in a similar debt situation as we were - the amount is not crazy huge, but it can seem daunting when you are charged 25%+ interest every month. 

This move will save us thousands in interest for basically the same monthly payment. It also gives us something that my husband values -- a light at the end of the tunnel! Our loan is for 3 years, with no early payoff penalties, so we are shooting to pay it off in 2 years. 

Credit card debt can seem endless; the snowball method is great & works for some people, but not everyone. I'm so glad we made the move to get the personal loan! 

@A.Gonzalez I bank with a credit union and I'm kicking myself a little. They sent me information about a personal loan a couple months back, but I didn't inquire more! The "promotion" or whatever it was seems to have ended, so I'm not sure what they've got now. Maybe'll I'll ask sometime soon. 

I very recently purchased a house, and I won't lie that I have NO IDEA what I'm doing or what half of the paperwork means. Since it was only back in August, I didn't think I should do much until everything is better established, if that makes sense.

@MountainFan If you just purchased your home in August, you don't have enough equity into it to do a home equity line of credit. Basically a HELC leverages the money you've paid into your home already (your "equity") & lets you borrow against that. I'm not an expert on this stuff by any means, but that's how it was explained to me.

As for your credit union - it's worth asking about! We sat down with someone & asked all of our questions (my husband had a LOT lol) before even starting the application, so you can always weigh your options before taking the hit to your credit score of a loan application. 

I think the hardest adjustment for anyone trying to pay off credit card debt (at least this was true for me) is considering that CC as untouchable & living solely within the means of your cash inflow. I do like the suggestion of giving one of them to a friend/ family member to save yourself the temptation... I might try that one myself! 

Good luck!!!! I hope you find whatever works for you! I'm on the same journey

To A. Gonzalez I'm interested in knowing what questions your husband asked in regards to the loan. I have less than $3000 in credit card debt, but my debt to credit ratio is high (if I said that correctly). Anyway, I want to consolidate because the interest rates are eating up any payments I'm making, so the principal just increases. 

@Melanie T his questions were related to our options (home equity, personal loan, secured loan, & the various choices within each), terms (we got it for 3 years), fees (no early payoff fees, standard late fees, etc), how it will affect our credit (a net improvement - we'll get dinged for the credit inquiry & for having a "maxed out" line of credit, but we'll show 2 cards getting paid off in full & for having a set loan instead of open line of credit), etc... he basically just wanted to know what we were getting in to.

In your case, have you thought about getting a balance transfer card? Your CC debt is so small, you could get a card that has a 0% intro APR on balance transfers, & as long as you pay it off within the terms, you'd have 0 interest. Intro periods are anywhere from 12 months to 20 depending on the card, so you have to decide if you can meet that payment every month because it is a shorter period than a loan would be. For example, a balance transfer card with an introductory period of 18 months for a total transfer of $3K would mean you'd pay $166.67 every month. Also, you'd have to be disciplined enough to not use any of the credit cards! but it's another option to consider. 

Add Reply


Related Content

Link copied to your clipboard.